talmud - page 63 of 463


















  




PASSAGES RELATING TO JESUS

49

prwterierunt duo pueri quorum unus caput 

operuit, alter revelavit. Dixit R. Eliezer, 

de illo qui Caput revelaverat, 'Spurius est'; 

R. jehoshua 

` Menstruw filius ' ; R. Aqiba 

'Spurius, et menstrua' filius.' Responderunt 

illi, 'Quomodo cor to inflat, ut verbis sociorum 

contradixeris !' Dixit eis `Rem

confirmabo.' 

Abut ad matrem pueri, quam vidit in foro 

sedentem dum legumina vendebat. Dixit 

ei ` Filia mea, si mihi id de quo rogabo 

respondeas, in seculum futurum to ducam.' 

Respondit illi

'


Jura mihi.' Juravit R. Aqiba 

ore, sed corde irritum fecit.' Dixit ei 'Filius 

hic tuus, qualis est ?' Respondit 'Quum 

thalamum introivi menstrua eram, et separavit 

a me conjux; paranymphus autem venit ad 

me, quapropter hic puer et spurius est et 

menstrua filius.' Responderunt

(Rabbini) 

'Magnus erat R. Aqiba, quum magistros

suos refutaret.' Ilia hora dixerunt ' Benedictus

Deus Israel, qui R. Agibm secretum suum

revelavit 1 ' 

Commentary.-I

give the above passage with some 

hesitation, because I doubt whether it has anything 

to do with the legendary history of Jesus. There is 

nothing to point him out as the child in question, 

and the few details which the story contains do not 

agree with what we have gathered hitherto as the 

Rabbinical account of the parentage of Jesus. So 

far as I know, this passage stands by itself, without 

being mentioned or referred to in any other Talmudic 

tractate ; and the tractate Kallah, in which it is found, 

is of later origin than the main body of the Talmud. 












Previous page Top Next page