talmud - page 39 of 463


















  




INTRODUCTION

25

Pentateuch and the five Megilloth

(i.e.

Ruth, Esther, 

Lamentations, Song of Songs, and Ecclesiastes). 

The ten Midrashim are of very various date, and 

were not gathered into one great collection till as 

late as the thirteenth century. Other Midrashim, of 

similar character, are Tanhuma, or Jelam'denu, on 

the Pentateuch, Pesiqta on selected passages, and 

Jalqut Shim'oni on the whole of the O.T., 

being a vast collection of extracts from earlier 

Midrashim. For details concerning these and many 

similar works, I refer the reader to the books of 

Zunz, Hamburger, and others mentioned above. My 

object in this introduction is not to give a biblio-

graphy of Rabbinical literature, but to indicate the 

general scope and method of that literature, so that 

the reader may have some idea of the sources whence 

the passages, which will presently be given, have 

been extracted. 

It will now be possible, as it is highly desirable, to

attempt an answer to the question, What is the

value, as historical evidence, of the Rabbinical

literature? Can any reliance be placed upon

statements found in works whose main purpose was

not to impart exact knowledge of facts, but to give

religious and moral teaching? 

Nothing is easier than to pick out from the 

Talmud and the Midrash statements in regard to 

historical events, which are palpably and even 

monstrously false, and that, too, when the events 

referred to were not very far removed from the 

lifetime of the author of the statements. And the 

conclusion is ready to hand, that if, in regard to 

events almost within living memory, such error

was 











Previous page Top Next page